Is Private Sector Participation (PSP) in water provision a universal model that should be applied to all developing countries? Is it the successful response to the failure of public service provision? Most importantly, does it benefit the poor?
A report co-sponsored by WaterAid and Tearfund, two UK-based international non-governmental organisations (NGOs), explores these issues presenting eight case studies and five desk studies from 12 different countries: Mozambique, Uganda, Ghana, the Philippines, Tanzania, Mexico, Nepal, Argentina, Brazil, England and Wales, South Africa and the US. The report places itself in the international debate surrounding the role of private transnational water utilities in developing countries and, in more general terms, on the replacement of the public sector by the private sector in the delivery of these services.
The case studies stand for themselves and do not try to teach a universal lesson that could be applied in all developing countries. In the case of water it is particularly difficult to infer a generalised trend because of the complex layers of relationships around it. In particular:
- Water can be analysed as a social good and access to it as a universal human right, or it can be seen as an economic good, and access to it as governed by the market rules of demand, supply and prices.
- For a successful water policy it is therefore necessary to take into account all the different uses of water: social, cultural, environmental and economic.
- All these aspects are not mutually exclusive and must be balanced, although priority must be given to human and environmental requirements.
- In relation to water, people can be considered as citizens or consumers but one must be careful in simply applying Western categories such as ‘citizen’ to developing countries.
PSP is now the main approach to water reform in developing countries. However, donors should not universally impose PSP as a condition for debt relief, trade or aid, without considering the specific context. Moreover, for the success of the reform, it is necessary that the poor are consulted and involved in the process. Four areas deserve particular attention:
- Capacity- building. The capacity of public authorities should not be undermined by PSP and they should not become dependent on private companies. The development of information and of regulatory institutions is also needed.
- Community involvement and transparency. The poor are usually seen as recipients of, not contributors to development. They do not have access to contract information and lack ownership. Governments’ investment in community involvement must therefore take equal priority to infrastructure construction.
- Financing. Cost recovery and cost contributions are usually managed from a narrow and technical perspective that does not consider the complexities of poverty. The ‘substitution effect’ must be considered, and water recovery cannot be pursued at the expenses of essentials such as health, food or education.
- Institutional reforms covering aspects such as regulation, transparency, accountability and good governance are needed.
